Immigration Article of the Day: Digital Border Searches After Riley v. California by Thomas Mann Miller
Wednesday, January 13, 2016
Immigration Article of the Day: Digital Border Searches After Riley v. California by Thomas Mann Miller
Digital Border Searches After Riley v. California by Thomas Mann Miller, University of Washington School of Law,December 9, 2015 Washington Law Review, Vol. 90, No. 4, 2015
Abstract: The federal government claims that the Fourth Amendment permits it to search digital information on cell phones, laptops, and other electronic devices at the international border without suspicion of criminal activity, much less a warrant. Until recently, federal courts have generally permitted these digital border searches, treating them no differently from searches of luggage. Courts that have limited digital border searches have required only that the government establish reasonable suspicion for the most exhaustive kind of digital search. The Supreme Court has not yet weighed in, but last year it held in Riley v. California that the search incident to arrest exception to the warrant requirement does not apply to cell phones. This Comment analyzes how Riley affects the border search doctrine and concludes that it should change the debate in significant ways. First, Riley establishes that digital searches are categorically different from physical searches. This undermines the first wave of border search decisions and suggests that courts will have to analyze digital searches differently. Second, the Court recognized that digital searches could be even more intrusive than the search of ones home. This finding weighs in favor of requiring at least reasonable suspicion, if not probable cause, for digital border searches. Third, the Court provides a test for determining when to deviate from the warrant requirement in light of new technology. The Courts analysis on this question supports reconsidering whether the border search exception traditionally applied to searches of persons and physical property should apply to searches of digital information.
KJ
Related articles http://lawprofessors.typepad.com/immigration/2016/01/digital-border-searches-after-riley-v-california-thomas-mann-miller-university-of-washington-school-of-law-december-9-2015.html
Current Affairs | Permalink
CommentsPost a comment